The short answer
Most verbs just add -ed or -ing: rain, rained, raining. Three kinds of base word change. A silent e drops (skate, skating), one short vowel and one final consonant double the consonant (clap, clapped), and a consonant before y turns the y to i before -ed but keeps it before -ing (worry, worried, worrying). US spelling keeps one l in traveled, canceled and labeled.
Adding -ed or -ing to a verb is a four-way choice, and the last letters of the base word make it. Most words stay whole. A silent e drops off. A short word with one vowel and one final consonant doubles that consonant. A consonant before a final y turns the y to i, but only before -ed. This guide sets out each rule with the check students can do before they write, the exceptions that come up in 1st to 5th grade, and a list of words to play for each one.
Check the end of the base word, in this order
Students can run the same four questions on any verb. The first yes decides the spelling.
- Does it end in a silent e? Drop the e before -ing, and add only d for -ed: hope, hoping, hoped.
- Does it end in a consonant and y? Change the y to i before -ed, and keep it before -ing: fry, fried, frying.
- Does it end in one vowel and one consonant, with the stress on the last syllable? Double the consonant: clap, clapped, clapping.
- None of these? Just add the ending: rain, rained, raining.
Just add -ed or -ing
The rule. The base word stays exactly as it is: fish, fished, fishing; spell, spelled, spelling. This covers verbs ending in two consonants (print, yell), two vowel letters before the last consonant (rain, float), and w or x (show, mix).
The check. Cover the ending with a finger. If the whole base word is still there, letter for letter, the student used this rule.
Three sounds, one spelling. The ending -ed is always spelled the same way, but it says three different things. When the base word ends in a t or d sound, -ed adds a syllable: need-ed, print-ed. When the last sound is voiced, so the throat buzzes, as in rain and show, it sounds like d. When the last sound is voiceless, as in fish and mix, it sounds like t. Spelled by ear, fished could come out as fisht and rained as raind, so name the three sounds early and repeat that the spelling stays the same.
1st grade: just add -ed
The base word never changes. Listen to the ending: t in fished, d in rained, and an extra syllable in floated.
- fished
- mixed
- dressed
- rained
- showed
- spelled
- yelled
- floated
- needed
- printed
After the class plays this list, sort the words into t, d and extra-syllable columns. For a whole year of lists, see the 1st grade spelling words.
Drop the silent e
The rule. When a word ends in a silent e, drop the e before an ending that starts with a vowel: skate, skating; drive, driving; trade, trading. The word already has its e, so -ed adds only d: save, saved; like, liked.
The check. Is the e silent, and does the ending start with a vowel? Two yeses mean the e goes. Before an ending that starts with a consonant, the e stays: hopeful, safely, movement.
Exceptions. In see and agree, the final e is part of the vowel sound, so it stays: seeing, agreeing. Canoe keeps its e too: canoeing. Words ending in ie change to y before -ing: tie, tying. In later grades, a few words keep the e before -able, such as manageable.
2nd and 3rd grade: drop the silent e
Every base word ends in a silent e. It drops before -ing (skate, skating), and -ed adds only d (save, saved).
- skating
- waving
- shining
- driving
- biking
- chased
- saved
- liked
- hoped
- traded
Double the last consonant
The 1-1-1 rule. A word with one syllable, one vowel and one final consonant doubles that consonant before an ending that starts with a vowel: clap, clapped; step, stepped; run, running. Compare hopping, from hop, with hoping, from hope: the double p is the only thing that tells them apart.
The check. Count back from the end: one consonant, one vowel, one syllable. Three ones mean double. Anything else means just add: jump has two consonants, rain has two vowels. Words ending in w, x or y never double: snowing, mixed, sprayed.
The stressed-syllable rule. A longer word doubles only when its last syllable carries the stress: be-GIN, beginning; pre-FER, preferred; per-MIT, permitted. When the stress comes earlier, just add: VIS-it, visited; O-pen, opened. Have students say the word and clap on the strong beat before they decide.
The US single l. Travel, cancel and label are stressed on the first syllable, so US spelling follows the stress rule and keeps one l: traveled, traveling, canceled, labeled. The GPO Style Manual, the US government’s printing guide, lists these single-l forms as preferred, and the American Heritage Dictionary gives them first. British and Australian spelling double the l whatever the stress (travelled), so books and lists from those countries spell these words differently. Words stressed on the last syllable double in both places: controlled, excelled.
2nd to 5th grade: double the last consonant, or keep one l
Short words with one vowel and one final consonant double it. Begin, prefer and permit double because the last syllable is stressed. Travel, cancel and label are stressed first, so US spelling keeps one l.
- clapped
- stepped
- zipped
- running
- beginning
- preferred
- permitted
- traveled
- canceled
- labeled
Standard L.3.2e gives sitting as an example of adding a suffix. For more lists at that level, see the 3rd grade spelling words.
Change y to i, or keep it
The rule. When a consonant comes before a final y, change the y to i before -ed: worry, worried; apply, applied; multiply, multiplied. Before -ing, keep the y: worrying, applying, multiplying. Changing it there would put two i’s side by side.
The check. Cover the y and look at the letter before it. A consonant means i, unless the ending is -ing. A vowel means the y stays every time: spray, sprayed; enjoy, enjoyed; annoy, annoyed.
Exceptions. Say, pay and lay break the vowel rule: said, paid, laid. Teach them together as a small set. The same y to i change comes back with -es, -er and -est (cries, happier, busiest), so a student who knows it here is ready for those.
3rd and 4th grade: change y to i, or keep it
After a consonant, y turns to i before -ed and stays before -ing: worry, worried, worrying. After a vowel, y stays: spray, sprayed.
- worried
- worrying
- fried
- frying
- applied
- applying
- multiplied
- multiplying
- sprayed
- annoyed
When to teach each rule
The Common Core names the skills by grade without setting an order for the rules. This order follows its examples where it gives them:
- 1st grade: just add. Standard L.1.4c uses look, looks, looked and looking, a base word that never changes. Teach the three sounds of -ed here.
- 2nd grade: drop the e and the 1-1-1 rule. Students decode words with suffixes (RF.2.3d), which is a good time to point out hoping and hopping side by side.
- 3rd grade: all three changes. Standard L.3.2e gives sitting, smiled and cries as examples: doubling, a dropped e and y to i.
- 4th and 5th grade: longer words. Add the stressed-syllable rule and the single l once students can hear which syllable is stressed.
The IES practice guide on foundational reading skills recommends teaching suffixes such as -s, -ed and -ing and having students build words with them, adding -ing to park, call and sing, then reading the new words aloud.
Practicing the rules with a class link
Spelling Stream for Teachers turns a word list into games your class plays in any web browser, with each word read aloud in US English. It’s free, with no student logins and no ads. Press Make it a class list under any set above, sign up free, change words if you like, and share one link.
- Scramble mixes up every letter, so students have to place both letters of a double and the i where the y was.
- Missing letter takes letters out of each word. When the gap is half of a double, or the l in traveled, students need the rule to fill it.
- Flashcards has students hear the word and spell it out loud before they flip the card. Ask them to say the rule first: “clap, one short vowel, double the p.”
Once all four rules are taught, mix two or three words from each set into one review list so students have to choose the rule every time. Each list gets its own link, so a group still working on just add can play a different list from a group on doubling. Families can open the class list in the free Spelling Stream app and keep practicing on their own device. For a week-by-week plan, see the weekly spelling routine, and for more spelling words by grade, start at the grade hub.
Where the rules sit in the Common Core
The Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts cover adding suffixes in these standards:
- L.1.4c: “Identify frequently occurring root words (e.g., look) and their inflectional forms (e.g., looks, looked, looking).”
- RF.1.3f: “Read words with inflectional endings.”
- RF.2.3d: “Decode words with common prefixes and suffixes.”
- L.3.2e: “Use conventional spelling for high-frequency and other studied words and for adding suffixes to base words (e.g., sitting, smiled, cries, happiness).”
- L.3.2f: “Use spelling patterns and generalizations (e.g., word families, position-based spellings, syllable patterns, ending rules, meaningful word parts) in writing words.”
Many states publish their own English language arts standards, so check this order against your state’s standards and your school’s scope and sequence.
Sources: Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts, SUNY Geneseo, Conventions of College Writing: Spelling, GPO Style Manual (2016), chapter 5, American Heritage Dictionary, Dictionary.com, cancel, Macquarie Dictionary grammar guide, Baruch College, Tools for Clear Speech: -ed endings, IES practice guide, Foundational Skills to Support Reading for Understanding.
Common Core State Standards quoted on this page: © Copyright 2010. National Governors Association Center for Best Practices and Council of Chief State School Officers. All rights reserved.
Questions
What is the doubling rule in spelling?
When a word ends in one vowel and one consonant, double the consonant before an ending that starts with a vowel if the word has one syllable or its last syllable is stressed: clap, clapped; begin, beginning. If the stress comes earlier, don’t double: visit, visited. Words ending in w, x or y never double.
Is it traveled or travelled?
Traveled, in US spelling. Travel is stressed on its first syllable, so the l stays single: traveled, traveling, and the same for canceled and labeled. British and Australian spelling double the l. Words stressed on the last syllable double in both: controlled, excelled.
What are the three sounds of -ed?
After a t or d sound, -ed adds a syllable: needed, printed. After a voiced sound, it sounds like d: rained, showed. After a voiceless sound, it sounds like t: fished, mixed. The spelling is -ed every time.
Why does the y stay in worrying?
The y only changes before an ending that doesn’t start with i. Changing it before -ing would put two i’s together, so the y stays: worrying, frying, applying. Before -ed it changes: worried, fried, applied.
What grade learns the rules for adding suffixes?
In the Common Core, 1st graders identify a root word and its inflectional forms, such as look, looks, looked and looking. Standard L.3.2e asks 3rd graders to spell words with suffixes added, with sitting, smiled and cries as its examples: one word for each change to the base word.

